The other day a headline came into my view that talks about the correlation between the use of erythritol (the sugar alcohol) and cardiac incidents. More specifically, the Cleveland Clinic is citing that it can induce blood clot formation. Erythritol is commonly used as a “filler” to augment natural sweeteners like monk fruit or stevia, or to offset the aftertastes of these substances so that they’ re more reminiscent of true sugar. What we like about erythritol is that it is cheap, a true net zero in terms of blood glucose impacts, extremely sweet, has less side GI side effects than other sugar alcohols, and a little bit goes a long way. For anyone who enjoys a sweet flavor, it’s a God sent. For diabetics or anyone conscious of their sugar intake, it is an ingredient brought to us by food science that we don’t want to take back. So, what does this new study really mean?

It ultimately means nothing (yet) because it is inconclusive. The studies involved participants who are already predisposed to heart issues because of other co-morbidities. Study participants were over 60 years old, either had cardiovascular disease already or were at high risk because of pre-existing conditions like diabetes and hypertension. Their use of erythritol is due to a condition that requires it as a sugar replacement. If it’s not a nutritional requirement, their predisposition to heart issues likely comes from a medication they’re taking that has nothing to do with blood sugar issues. Or, they smoke.

Need I point out that heart disease or heart issues is the leading cause of death in America. Are all of those deaths from erythritol? It is laughable given the current evidence to really even make an assumption here. Erythritol (in all its newfound food science glory) is not responsible for this decades long truth. It wasn’t until the 90’s that we really start to see its popularity skyrocket after it was approved for use in food and we saw an uptick in its use in packaged/processed foods attempting to follow the doctrine of “Do no harm” by not hijacking people’s brains with sugar induced serotonin highs. That being said, we don’t have a ton of long term data on the use of a lot of new sugar alternatives because they are a scientific achievement of the modern day. Much like we don’t have a ton of data on new pharmaceuticals that come to market, medical devices, or novel cleaning ingredients designed to replace the endocrine disruptors we are now trying to avoid. Each iteration of harmful compounds gets us closer to truly harmless ingredients (IMO) as science progresses.

Why do I believe this? Well, remember the pink saccharine packets holding the aptly branded “Sweet & Low?” The FDA actually tried to recall that substance at one point because of conclusive evidence that cyclamate causes cancer and concerns over phenylalanine in aspartame. Why was it still retailed? Because consumers wanted it. If you are prevented from enjoying a slow death a la Mother Nature’s gift of natural sugar, you will take the next best thing so that you can partake. We’re hardwired as a species to enjoy and seek out sweet foods. Diabetics and the sugar conscious alike were fine taking the risk with saccharin because everyone knows that risk isn’t synonymous with certainty, and they were still likely better off with the pink than the white table sugar that was certain to alter blood sugar and bodily health. Fast forward to Splenda in the yellow packets that are popular today. About a decade ago, CSPI had a neutral rating on the substance citing it was okay to use in moderation. It has since been downgraded to a rating that says to limit consumption. It’s a form of bleached sugar and some recent data has been rolling in that it may be linked to kidney trouble in susceptible populations long term. The knowledge of how it is metabolized and its byproduct of dioxin in vivo is now (more) common knowledge. Again, people using Splenda likely have a predisposition to metabolic or chronic disease that impacts the kidneys, and that is why they use it in the first place. Or, they’re a foodie looking for a responsible sugar alternative. Time and tightly controlled variables are the teller. As we make progress, (yes, food science ingredients that do less harm are in fact progress, and fun) we should not be fear mongering people away from these advancements with headlines like Erythritol causes heart attacks. The benefits actually still far outweigh the risks at this time, and the study designs were not representative of a healthy population without an existing predisposition or risk factor. Therefore, it’s unfair and unethical to scare people away from something that could help them. It’s akin to saying you shouldn’t eat bananas because of the sugar. It’s just plain wrong and lacks critical thinking.

Marion Nestle, the famous molecular biologist, nutritionist, and public health advocate actually weighed in on this recent headline citing what I am saying above. She is quoted in the recent New York Times article, “You take in erythritol, you will not die on the spot. You will not.” If you consume this cheap, artificial, bulk adding, cost reducing sweetener, you are consuming a substance that hasn’t stood the test of time on safety. But, it’s still by and large better than the ones we’ve already ruled out or attempting to achieve the same level of sweetness with real sugar.

When we get ahold of studies like this recent one published in Nature that could hold elements of a formerly unknown truth, we would all be wise to speak the full truth just like Nestle. This is especially true of health professionals, the media, and marketers. This is ultimately a post about ethics. It is essential to report the facts, but it is NEVER ethical to fear monger with hyperbole when you have a level of wisdom or expertise that your audience does not.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from THE Co.

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading